A Fresh Perspective on Professor Moriarty
Moriarty the Patriot is one of Japan’s newer efforts at retelling the stories of Sherlock Holmes, this time through the lens of his mortal enemy: Professor James Moriarty. This fresh take on the classic narrative introduces a captivating twist by portraying Moriarty not merely as a criminal mastermind but as a complex and morally ambiguous character, offering viewers a deeper exploration of his motivations and the socio-political context of Victorian-era England. With its intriguing blend of detective work, political intrigue, and thought-provoking character development, the series has garnered a devoted following, showcasing the enduring appeal of the timeless Holmes universe in our ever-evolving entertainment landscape. As creators continue to breathe new life into this iconic world, the legacy of Sherlock Holmes and his adversaries seems destined to thrive for future generations.
The Familiar Trend of Turning Villains into Antiheroes
The premise of Moriarty the Patriot may not be particularly original, as it follows the popular trend of attempting to turn a villainous character into an antihero by providing them with a justifiable motivation. However, what sets this adaptation apart is its compelling exploration of the complexities within the character of Moriarty. Despite belonging to the noble class through birthright or circumstance, Moriarty’s deep-seated disdain for the rigid class system of late 19th century Britain drives him and his brothers to use crime to dismantle what they perceive as the oppressive and corrupt foundations of their society.
This nuanced approach to Moriarty’s character challenges viewers to question the line between hero and villain as he embarks on his morally ambiguous quest to rectify the world’s injustices. Moriarty the Patriot delves into the psychological and philosophical aspects of its characters, making it more than just a straightforward adaptation of the Holmes universe. By exploring the tension between noble intent and questionable means, the series provides a thought-provoking narrative that encourages audiences to reconsider their definitions of right and wrong, all within the backdrop of a meticulously recreated Victorian-era London.
A Departure from Traditional Sherlockian Formulas
As with most Sherlock stories, Moriarty the Patriot is classified as a crime thriller, and while crime undeniably plays a central role in the series, its primary focus diverges from the traditional formula. Unlike the typical Sherlockian narratives centered around the creation and resolution of crimes or the intense cat-and-mouse games between Sherlock and Moriarty, these elements take a backseat in Moriarty the Patriot. Instead, the series takes a more unique approach.
Moriarty the Patriot regularly draws inspiration from famous Sherlock Holmes tales, such as A Study in Scarlet, but simplifies and reimagines them to an amusing degree. This creative deviation serves the purpose of propelling the overarching story of the Moriarty family and their pursuit of societal change. By weaving these adaptations into the broader narrative, the series maintains the audience’s interest in the compelling Moriarty characters and their endeavors to reshape the world, even as it playfully reshapes and reinterprets familiar Holmesian adventures. In doing so, it offers a fresh perspective on the classic source material, ensuring that it remains engaging and thought-provoking for both long-time Sherlock enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
Patriotism Explored
The real essence of Moriarty the Patriot lies in the latter part of its title, dealing with the profound idea of patriotism. It is in the exploration of the concept of patriotism that the series truly shines. All three Moriarty brothers share a common goal: the complete dismantling of the oppressive class system in Britain to usher in a society defined by equality and fairness for all its citizens.
The series’s commitment to this message becomes strikingly clear, especially in Episodes 2 and 3 of the anime, where the Moriarty brothers are willing to go to extreme lengths, even contemplating the annihilation of their own family, to achieve their vision of a more just world. This unwavering dedication to their cause leaves little room for moral ambiguity. The nobles in the series are portrayed as despicable, and the lower-class individuals are depicted as suffering under the weight of a system that treats them with brutal unfairness.
The contrast between the haves and the have-nots is so stark that there is no room for doubt regarding the righteousness of the Moriartys’ motivations. The series underscores the notion that their brand of patriotism stems from a genuine desire for societal transformation, making their actions appear justifiable in the face of an unyielding class struggle. In doing so, Moriarty the Patriot engages its audience in thought-provoking discussions on the nature of justice, social reform, and the sacrifices one must make for the greater good.
Admirable Egalitarian Social Justice Message
While the egalitarian social justice message of Moriarty the Patriot is undoubtedly admirable, it might not be conveyed with the same level of intellectual depth and intricacy found in some other works that explore similar themes, like The Promised Neverland or Psycho-Pass (notably featuring character designs by the same artist, Hikaru Miyoshi). Nonetheless, what sets Moriarty the Patriot apart is its compelling dive into the pragmatic and pragmatic nature of achieving social change, which feels exceptionally relevant to the political climate of the year 2020.
The series does not merely focus on idealistic solutions to societal issues but delves into the intricate complexities of pursuing reform in a world marked by entrenched power structures, systemic inequalities, and political maneuvering. In doing so, it forces viewers to confront the reality that change often necessitates a nuanced and multifaceted approach, one that may involve unconventional methods and moral dilemmas.
Amid these discussions, Moriarty the Patriot manages to strike a chord with its audience by acknowledging the multifaceted nature of social change, emphasizing the importance of adapting strategies to address the evolving challenges of the era. As the world grappled with pressing issues in 2020, this political message resonated strongly, offering a timely reflection on the quest for real change and unity in society, making the series a thought-provoking and relevant addition to the anime landscape.
A Society Rife with Injustice
Moriarty the Patriot unfolds its narrative in the backdrop of 19th century Britain, when wealth and power were overwhelmingly concentrated among the privileged nobility, leaving the lower class seething with resentment and grievances. A significant portion of the population, including women and rural residents, were denied the right to vote, which fueled their discontent with a society that seemed inherently unjust.
On the surface, the Moriarty brothers appear to have chosen a life of crime as a means to exact vengeance upon those in power, aiming to expose the misdeeds of the nobles and to deliver retribution in the process. However, their true strategy is more profound. They seek to create a common adversary for the oppressed masses and the entrenched nobility, uniting them in a shared cause that forces the nobles to recognize their dependence on the common people and vice versa. In this way, the Moriartys aspire to sow the seeds of a safer and more just society by breaking down class divisions and fostering mutual understanding and cooperation.
This intricate plan shares similarities with Lelouch vi Britannia’s final scheme in Code Geass, where he also aimed to unite disparate factions by presenting a common enemy, demonstrating the thematic depth of Moriarty the Patriot‘s storytelling. As the series explores the dynamics of power, manipulation, and societal transformation, it offers viewers a rich and thought-provoking narrative that resonates with the themes of unity, sacrifice, and the quest for a better world, all set against the backdrop of a captivating historical setting.
Crime as a Catalyst for Social Change
The decision to employ crime as a means of instigating social change in Moriarty the Patriot can be traced back to a profound understanding of history and the patterns of significant societal transformation. When examining the annals of history, it becomes evident that major social upheaval and reform often emerge from times of immense turmoil and tragedy. The French Revolution, for instance, was a direct response to rampant poverty and oppressive taxation. At the same time, the formation of the United Nations was catalyzed by the horrors of World War II. The tragic murder of Emmett Till played a pivotal role in galvanizing the civil rights movement in the United States.
During peaceful times, people often become complacent with their circumstances, making it challenging to inspire major changes without the injection of strong emotions and a sense of urgency. As history has repeatedly demonstrated, it is during these periods of turmoil that a common enemy or adversary emerges to unite the masses against a shared cause. Monarchy and feudalism became the targets of the French Revolution, the Nazis represented a global evil during World War II, and the civil rights movement confronted the deeply entrenched racism of its era.
Similarly, the Moriarty brothers in the series deliberately chose the path of crime to evoke strong reactions from the people and the nobility alike. By adopting the role of villains, they hoped to create a formidable adversary that would compel society to confront its injustices and demand change. In doing so, Moriarty the Patriot offers a compelling exploration of the underlying mechanisms of social transformation and the pivotal role that strong emotions and a common enemy can play in inspiring individuals to unite for a better and more just world.
The Potential for Chaos Amidst Social Instability
However, it is crucial to recognize that while periods of significant instability can indeed catalyze social change, they also carry the potential for descending into chaos. In such situations, the ruling class may exploit the fear and uncertainty generated by the upheaval and redirect it towards war or other means to maintain their grip on power. This dynamic underscores the delicate balance between harnessing societal discontent for positive reform and the risk of being manipulated to perpetuate the status quo.
It is precisely where Sherlock Holmes assumes a pivotal role within the narrative of Moriarty the Patriot. He represents a force for stability amid the chaos, a figure who can restore order and uphold justice in a society teetering on the edge of anarchy. While Holmes may not align himself with the nobles, he remains highly effective at apprehending criminals, even those who target the aristocracy. He operates as an enigmatic and independent figure, navigating the intricate web of society’s rules and norms, yet he remains committed to seeking the truth and administering justice.
For the common people enduring the tumultuous times depicted in the series, Sherlock Holmes emerges as their beacon of hope. He is the one constant they can rely upon in a world spiraling into disorder, providing a glimmer of assurance that justice can prevail even in the most turbulent circumstances. In this way, Holmes symbolizes the enduring human need for a stabilizing force during periods of uncertainty and upheaval, making him a central figure in the struggle for societal transformation portrayed in Moriarty the Patriot.
The Complex Ethical Dilemma of Ends Justifying Means
By setting the Moriarty brothers against Sherlock Holmes, the narrative in Moriarty the Patriot strategically introduces the complex ethical dilemma of whether the end justifies the means. Beyond this moral conundrum, the series also underscores the clash of two contrasting ideologies for effecting social change: the radical approach of dismantling and rebuilding society from the ground up, as championed by the Moriartys, or the more gradual path of making incremental changes from within the existing system, embodied by Sherlock Holmes. This thematic tension raises profound questions about the most effective route to rectify societal injustices and the potential sacrifices entailed in each approach.
As the story unfolds, it becomes evident that there is no one-size-fits-all answer to this dilemma. The intricacies of each situation and the complexities of human nature make it challenging to assert which path is superior definitively. What remains undeniably clear, however, is the tenacity of the ruling class in their efforts to maintain their grip on power. They will employ any means necessary, including manipulating the media and spreading rumors, to preserve the existing order and thwart challenges to their authority. In the face of such opposition, the characters of Moriarty the Patriot navigate the treacherous terrain of societal change, wrestling with the moral quandaries and strategic decisions that come with their respective methods, all while striving to unmask the truths concealed behind the façade of power and privilege.
Intentional Resonance with Recent Events
If the description of Moriarty the Patriot resonates with recent events in any capacity, it is highly probable that this resonance is intentional. The series’ creators have demonstrated a deliberate and unapologetic approach to weaving contemporary socio-political issues into the narrative, employing a turbulent historical period as a backdrop to draw parallels with the challenges of modern society. This narrative device serves as a platform for addressing complex themes such as geopolitics, the influence of the military-industrial complex, and the nuances of community policing, among others.
While Moriarty the Patriot may not necessarily be the pinnacle of crime storytelling or the most faithful Sherlock Holmes adaptation available, it distinguishes itself as a highly engaging and thought-provoking political thriller. It offers viewers not only a thrilling storyline but also a canvas on which to contemplate and discuss pertinent ideas during tumultuous political climates akin to a wild election season. The series encourages its audience to reflect on the parallels between historical contexts and contemporary challenges, making it a compelling and relevant piece of storytelling that provokes thought and discussion well beyond its entertainment value.
Bibliography
- Collins, H. (2022). Moriarty the Patriot’s class war is far from history in the UK. Anime Feminist.
- Qu, G. (2021). Moriarty the Patriot Review: Classic Characters Given a Twist. Anime Trending.
- Wu, X. (2020). Moriarty the Patriot Is a Political Anime, Just Not in the Way You Think. CBR.
- Zhdanova, M. (2020). REVIEW: Moriarty the Patriot is SO MUCH. WWAC.