Analyzing Kurt Cobain’s Profound Poetry
When we analyze a profound quote from Kurt Cobain’s poetry, we find that the verses in Smells Like Teen Spirit can conjure up feelings of apathy, pessimism, and disillusionment all at once. He expressed in a raspy voice that he struggled to locate meaning, subsequently uttering phrases like “Whatever” and “It’s over.” It conveys his message, suggesting that life is ultimately futile, a perspective shared by Bob Hince, a 26-year-old who, despite completing six years of study in molecular biology, now embarks on a journey to Alaska to work as a salmon fisherman. His crimson-dyed hair, almost concealing his eyes, remains concealed behind his retro Buddy Holly glasses as he casually sips on miniature Bloody Marys, seemingly oblivious to Flake, the band meandering on the stage. It encapsulates a sense of ambivalence, reflecting our uncertainty at this juncture.
We find ourselves at a loss, unsure of how to proceed. Hince confessed that his job prospects stirred intense anger within him, a sentiment that resonates with all of us, evoking a sense of monotony and a feeling of powerlessness over our circumstances. All these emotions are woven into the music; if one seeks frustration, one can discern it in Cobain’s impassioned vocals and the tormenting strains of the metallic guitar. Consider the urgency of Come As You Are, urging us to “Take your time, hurry up,” and the suppressed anger evident in Tourette’s, characterized by hoarse mutterings on In Utero with lyrics like “Bastard, damn, piss.” Untrained ears may find this new material unsettling.
Furthermore, punk, with its nearly identical message, has been a presence for quite some time. For instance, it has been nearly two decades since the Sex Pistols directed their invectives at Bill Grundy. Cobain acknowledged this, admitting they were a 1990s iteration of Cheap Trick. At one juncture, he consistently praised charming but less-known British punk bands like Vaselines and Raincoats. Nevertheless, punk achieved a different breakthrough in the United States than in the UK. While the Sex Pistols may have reshaped the British pop scene, punk remained on the fringes in the US.
According to Jeff Gilbert, a Guitar World writer based in Seattle, it failed to captivate the American audience. The result was a void quickly filled by Cobain, who softened us, and Nirvana genuinely provided a significant impetus. For instance, what Nevermind accomplished in the UK mirrored on the other side of the Atlantic. However, Cobain went beyond merely awakening punk by revisiting the timeless theme of teenage rebellion. He possessed an innate understanding of what set the suffering of his listeners apart from that of their predecessors, an insight highlighted by Newsweek’s assertion that grunge emerges when children of divorce wield guitars. Among the challenges of discussing Generation X, amidst all the debates, one of the most challenging aspects is that more than any other historical group, they emerged from tumultuous family backgrounds.
The Iconic Unplugged Performance
For many individuals, the enduring image of Cobain is him seated on stage wearing torn jeans and a worn-out green cardigan, leading Nirvana in a rendition of The Man Who Sold the World that was broadcast on MTV’s Unplugged in November 1993. Shortly after this performance, on April 8, 1994, Cobain tragically took his own life in the guesthouse of his suburban Seattle residence. The significance of the MTV Unplugged performance cannot be overstated, especially when delving into the lyrics crafted or selected by Cobain. Initially composed by David Bowie in 1970, The Man Who Sold the World quickly became the standout piece of the set. The song carries profound metaphors that portray the internal conflict between Bowie and his alter ego, Ziggy Stardust. Cobain’s interpretation of this 1970s-style progressive rock song serves as a poignant reminder to the audience that the expressive essence of grunge was deeply intertwined with imagery related to the physical body, sexuality, and identity. Even though this moment unfolded years after Nirvana’s meteoric rise, the performance of The Man Who Sold the World exemplifies the unique principles that shaped Cobain’s lyrics and the underlying meaning of his music.
Cobain and, consequently, Nirvana were integral to the grunge movement. In simple terms, grunge is a musical genre that originated in the mid-1980s in Seattle, Washington. The label “grunge” was affixed to bands from the Pacific Northwest who blended heavy metal and punk elements. On closer examination, Horsfall contends that grunge music was a genre that deviated from the norm. Akin to all forms of deviant music, grunge music primarily focused on three key functions: offering social criticism, disseminating news, and providing catharsis for significant events. Although there were numerous popular grunge bands during this era, including Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, Screaming Trees, Alice in Chains, and Mother Love Bone, to name a few, Nirvana stood out as the quintessential grunge band due to Cobain’s intricate persona and the magnetic allure of his lyrics.
Cobain’s lyrics mirror his perspective on the disintegration of modernity. He employed vivid metaphors centered around the human form, bodily fluids, suicide, violence, sex, and drugs. These underlying narratives were a rallying cry for Generation X and became a scholarly research subject. Cobain’s prose keenly captured the agony experienced by Generation X. He depicted their pain and fears, the tension they grappled with between their private and personal spaces, and particularly the angst stemming from the negative judgments cast upon them by Baby Boomers and individuals from the Greatest Generation, who labeled them as shallow, lazy, and amoral. Although melody always took precedence for Cobain, his choice of words consistently showcased originality, even when he explored themes that had been present for decades. For instance, All Apologies was both an act of confession and contrition for his humanity, encapsulated in the phrase “all in all is all we are.”
Unusual Family Background
According to Bob’s acquaintance, Mara Rivet (an assistant at Tower Records), she’s only acquainted with two individuals whose parents haven’t divorced, and one of them is her mother, who experienced a tragic incident of being shot. She is cognizant that Cobain’s parents, a secretary and an auto mechanic, parted ways when he was ten. Bob, Mara, and their circle of friends grasp Cobain’s actions when he travels to Hawaii to marry Courtney Love, the frontwoman of the band Hole, in 1992. They observed the wedding ceremony without knowing that Cobain was administered heroin then. They have heard the celebrity declare that he proposed to Love because she was the world’s finest person, and they have witnessed him revealing scars on his back as proof of his commitment.
Nevertheless, they connected it to a different, deeper motive, fully comprehending the longing to discover a home and be a part of a family. In Mara’s perspective, he was searching for something akin to the Brady Bunch but could not find it, exemplifying one of the cherished cultural symbols for X-ers. She herself left her home after her parent’s separation and held Cobain responsible for leaving behind a future where 19-month-old Frances Bean would lack similar parents. After witnessing Cobain’s futile endeavors to find domestic happiness, her outlook became even more pessimistic. Her message was not subtle, notwithstanding the idealism of the flower power era or even the rebellious punk ethos.
Grunge represented a movement devoid of coherent politics, a realm where small actions were undertaken, but everyone understood that it would ultimately be futile. Consequently, Kurt rarely engaged in politics, occasionally encouraging his fans to support LGBTQ+ and women’s rights. However, he frequently expressed his fondness for firearms, keeping an M-16 and 10,000 rounds of ammunition in the hall closet, inadvertently echoing right-wing rhetoric regarding Americans’ right to self-defense. It is what distinguishes Nirvana and their generation from previous youth rebellions.
Hippies and punks both constituted public movements, whether aimed at opposing the Vietnam War or promoting anarchy in the UK. Both harbored beliefs in the potential for change. But Cobain, akin to the twenty-somethings who listened to his music, was an introverted and self-centered individual. He recognized that this introspection was not attractive, once describing his public image as that of a schizophrenic, angry, complaining, and perpetually suicidal individual. However, it only fueled his self-loathing. In this aspect, he served as a role model for Generation X.
Media Frenzy Over Cobain’s Suicide
Cobain’s suicide garnered extensive attention from various newspapers, magazines, and radio and television programs. In the days and months following April 8, numerous journalists and reporters extensively covered his death, asserting that this media exposure solidified and firmly established his status as a generational icon. Among the most notable pieces of coverage was Strauss’ Rolling Stone article. This article looked back a month to an apparent suicide attempt in Rome and then delved into Cobain’s final days. Strauss provided a detailed account of Cobain’s steps leading up to April 8 and described the grief and confusion experienced by many upon learning the news. He also highlighted that the Seattle Crisis Clinic received approximately 100 more calls than usual and a few cases of copycat suicides. The public’s response to Cobain’s suicide gave rise to the second prevailing theme in the academic literature concerning Cobain: examining how Cobain’s suicide resonated with the general public.
Baume, Cantor, and Rolfe conducted a study involving over 300 websites that documented Cobain’s life, death, and music. In numerous instances, they discovered that the star’s suicide note and death certificate had been posted online. The availability of this material, coupled with extensive media coverage, raised concerns related to the Werther effect mentioned by Jobes, Berman, O’Carroll, Eastgard, and Knickmeyer. This effect posits that a celebrity’s death has the potential to influence vulnerable youth to mimic such actions. Fortunately, studies did not confirm the existence of the Werther Effect.
Martin and Koo examined the overall suicide rate in Australia in 1994 among individuals aged 15 to 24. They found that the number of suicides matched the figures for the same period in the previous five years. Berman, Jobes, and O’Carroll collected data from King County, Washington, where Cobain lived, and discovered fewer suicides in 1994 compared to 1993. However, Jobes et al. explained a significant increase in suicide crisis calls following Cobain’s death. Although it is often anticipated that suicides increase when a beloved celebrity takes their own life, they hypothesized that the extensive media coverage, the graphic nature of Cobain’s suicide, and outreach interventions may have discouraged copycat suicides.
While the existing body of research on Cobain effectively analyzes various aspects of his life, work, and death, it predominantly focuses on the year of his death and the immediate aftermath. What seems to be missing are investigations and interpretations that delve into his ascent to stardom before 1994. Cobain’s suicide at the age of 27 has become a part of American folklore, often intertwined with narratives about Jim Morrison, Brian Jones, Jimi Hendrix, and Janis Joplin, all members of the 27 Club. However, Cobain’s legacy transcends a romanticized view of a life lived in the fast lane or as a club member. Unlike other 27 Club musicians who allegedly died from accidental drug overdoses, Cobain’s death was a deliberate act of suicide.
Furthermore, Cobain’s image and likeness continue to be more prominently utilized than those of the other 27 Club members, yet there is a lack of convincing explanations for this enduring appeal. In his song Serve the Servants, from Nirvana’s final studio album In Utero, Cobain sings the lyrics: “Teenage angst has paid off well, Now I’m bored and old.” While Kurt would have been 51 and Nirvana 32 in 2019, there remains a need for a deeper understanding of why the public continues to be drawn to these aged images and music.
Cobain’s Unconventional Suicide Note
Usually, Cobain’s suicide note, which was read by Love to thousands of people at the Seattle memorial service, did not contain complaints about the issues that were said to preoccupy the post-1965 generation, such as homelessness, divorce, and AIDS. Instead, it focused on Cobain’s chronic stomach condition, which he claimed drove him to use heroin as a form of self-medication. In the note, he even expressed gratitude for his hot and nauseous stomach, considering it a very precise disease. This condition, in a way, proved that Cobain’s pain had no external influence, as he felt it deep in his heart.
Despite the unconventional nature of his cause of death, dying from a stomachache was seen as quite reasonable for the prince of the naughty generation. According to Bob, the parents of this generation had built expectations that they could not fulfill, particularly regarding their future economic prospects. Cobain reflected on the worst qualities of Generation X, including passivity, self-pity, and the hope that their parents owed them a future. He was clever enough to convey these sentiments in his note.
During the memorial service, Cobain’s grieving widow, Love, reading his suicide note to the fans, was able to show a similar contempt for these issues. When she reached the part where Cobain complained about being a sad, small, and sensitive Pisces-Jesus man, she stopped reading and shouted at her deceased husband’s ghost to be quiet. This moment highlighted the complex emotions and dynamics surrounding Cobain’s life and death.
Cobain’s Fame and Expanding Fanbase
The simple explanation is that Cobain’s fame has grown parallel with his and Nirvana’s fanbase. Fandom is a common aspect of industrial societies and arises from the widespread production and distribution of entertainment related to specific performers, narratives, or genres. While Cobain will forever be linked to Generation X, the reality is that his iconic status has surpassed one generation. Today, people of all ages have developed a strong affection and connection to Cobain. Not only does Nirvana’s music continue to receive airplay, and their albums continue to sell, but the Internet and social media have also significantly sustained their fan following. In addition to websites, memes, Twitter trends, Facebook pages, and YouTube videos have been dedicated to Kurt Cobain. As the online fandom movement allows for a more personalized fan experience, the demographics and psychographics of those attracted to Cobain’s challenge to social norms extend beyond the youth of the 1990s. It suggests that Cobain’s fandom has expanded beyond a single demographic, potentially explaining the growth in his fame over the past 25 years.
However, a deeper, somewhat sinister explanation exists for the decades-long rise in Cobain’s popularity. Over time, Kurt Cobain has become a commodity. Marx introduced the concept of a commodity as an object external to us, an item that, through its properties, satisfies various human desires. In a sense, commodification characterizes the entire grunge subculture, of which Cobain and other musicians were a part. On one hand, their clothing and the values expressed through their performances and lyrics were strongly anti-materialistic.
On the other hand, they eagerly embraced fame and aspired to succeed as musicians, which contradicted the grunge movement’s essence. Essentially, these commodities held inherent contradictions. Cobain and his band were positioned at the opposite end of the American mainstream music spectrum and were seen by their fans as embodiments of resistance. Furthermore, as a subcultural movement, grunge was non-materialistic, making the commodities derived from it, as mentioned earlier, contrary to the movement’s philosophy. This paradox was present even during Cobain’s lifetime as he wrote songs and produced music. However, it appeared to gain momentum after his suicide. Every aspect of the singer’s life found its place in the market. Some of the most notable examples of commodities that emerged after his death, further contributing to his fame, were diaries filled with reflections predating his suicide. Ironically, these diaries also reinforced the idea that there needed to be a more general understanding regarding the struggles the musician was dealing with as he evolved into a rock star.
Publication of Cobain’s Diaries
Love published these diaries eight years after the grunge sensation tragically ended his life. In his autoethnography, Thackray, who meticulously documented the evolution of the grunge movement and Nirvana’s ascent, posits that Cobain would probably have been reluctant to share his journals with others. Thackray’s belief stems from his direct observations and close relationship with Cobain and Love.
Cobain’s name has been assimilated into consumer culture, where it is utilized to market various manufactured goods. Drawing inspiration from Nirvana’s Rape Me song, Borchard coined “raping Cobain” to elucidate how the Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Las Vegas leveraged the musician’s image to transform the remnants of his life into marketable commodities. Borchard critiqued the items showcased at the Hard Rock Hotel and Casino as a somberly ironic display, given that they contradicted the values that Cobain and the grunge movement sought to uphold. According to the author, Cobain’s suicide can be interpreted as a final, unambiguous declaration of pain and despair, wherein the artist reclaimed absolute authority over the interpretation of his art, representing a form of purity.
The concept that Cobain’s image has become a commodity is not novel. Fish was the first to propose that the tension between aesthetics and commodification lies at the core of Cobain’s celebrity status. As Fish expounds, despite Cobain’s lyrics and actions striving to distance themselves from mainstream culture, he and Nirvana ultimately evolved into mainstream icons and celebrities. Cobain’s success may have been his most significant downfall, as the more people embraced his expressions of alienation, the more isolated he became. Correspondingly, Cobain’s humanity has been supplanted by readily reproducible and widely distributable products bearing his likeness. Nonetheless, as we contend, the surge in Cobain’s iconic status over the past 25 years is intimately tied to celebrating and commercializing his image as an anti-hero.
Cobain has frequently been depicted as an anti-hero in popular media. Over time, publications like Time, The Village Voice, and Rolling Stone have all presented him in this light. The anti-hero label is intriguing because it presupposes that the person in question embodies an anti-establishment ethos that lacks many conventional hero qualities, essentially representing the opposite of what defines a traditional hero. Anti-heroes are characterized by imperfections, moral flaws, often a lack of physical prowess, and are frequently social outsiders. This concept of the anti-hero is not new; it has existed for centuries. Furthermore, the figure of the anti-hero has been utilized in various contexts, particularly in media and narratives directed at specific readers or viewers, such as those in the literary domain. Therefore, a more in-depth exploration of Cobain’s image as an anti-hero is essential, as it may shed light on crucial aspects of his increasing popularity that led to his transformation into a commodity, despite the messages conveyed by his music and the foundational ideas of his life philosophy.
Cobain’s Anti-Hero Image in Popular Media
Nevertheless, it is vital to acknowledge that starting in the 1990s, numerous anti-heroes began to gain mainstream acceptance, largely due to improvements in the quality of the genre itself. There are other explanations for this phenomenon: more than ever before, mainstream audiences encountered anti-heroes and embraced and supported them. While the list is extensive, some prominent anti-hero characters include Tim Burton’s Batman and the narrator/Tyler Durden from Fight Club. During this period, stores also expanded their offerings beyond media related to anti-heroes; they began selling associated merchandise, leading to commodification. It included posters, hats, T-shirts, lighters, and mugs.
The 1990s marked a pivotal moment for anti-heroes, as shortly after the decade ended, there was a surge in sales related to characters like Patrick Bateman, Dexter Morgan, and Walter White across various media forms such as box office hits, television series, DVDs, comics, and books. Today, Cobain’s Funko Pop! figurine is on the shelves of numerous FYE stores, alongside figures like Deadpool, Rocket from Guardians of the Galaxy, and Deadshot from Suicide Squad, among others. A consequence of this trend has been Cobain’s commodification.
Cobain was, instead, a rock star and the embodiment of a subcultural movement known as grunge. He was a genuine individual who embodied all the classic anti-hero traits, he was physically unassuming, rejected traditional masculinity, claimed a closer affinity to the female side of human nature, and yet held a fascination with firearms. In his music, he conveyed anti-institutional messages that delved into life’s complexities, especially those arising from acute anxiety related to a white, heterosexual, masculine identity. Kurt’s rejection of the role of being the voice of a generation further solidified his image as an anti-hero. He vehemently denied this role, asserting that his songs were merely artistic expressions. He wanted nothing to do with being the voice of Generation X. Interestingly, even though his music was composed and recorded three decades ago, his lyrics continue to offer a valid critique of the troubled society we live in today.
On one hand, as Cobain’s fans persist in following and supporting him and his music, they collectively construct a shared reality in which he assumes a central position. There is an importance attributed to Cobain that his fans have come to acknowledge and widely publicize through their interactions, both online and offline. On the other hand, even the economic processes tied to the co-optation of his image fundamentally involve communication. While there is an assumption that commercialization is primarily driven by market forces, especially in a consumer-driven society like the United States, communication still plays a significant role. The creation of a brand or brand image hinges on conveyed messages. Concerning Kurt Cobain, as organizations continue to exploit his image as an anti-hero, consumers subsequently adopt this image as their reality.
Aberdeen’s Potential for Reverence
Aberdeen, Washington, has not yet achieved the status of a revered place, but it could attain that recognition soon. The walls of the burnt-down restaurant already bear graffiti that reads “Kurt Cobain RIP.” This economically disadvantaged and dilapidated town, home to around 16,000 loggers, loggers, and fishermen, is the birthplace of the delicate poet and artist with blond hair and blue eyes. One can spot trucks laden with logs stacked like cigarettes along the 100-mile stretch of road connecting this town to Seattle. Wood is abundant, with fir and pine trees etching the sky like sharp pencils and houses designed with shingles, including the well-kept greenhouse where Kurt Cobain’s mother still lives. Her son was born in February 1967, and she later mentioned that she experienced seven years of happiness following his birth. His parents divorced when he was eight years old, and he did not communicate with his father until he succeeded in the music industry. After the divorce, the young Cobain turned inward. Teachers at Aberdeen High School recall him as a reserved individual, someone other kids avoided.
While examining his art room, Hunter pointed out Kurt’s seat, close to his own. A rock station frequently played on the radio at that time. Cobain used to offer critiques, song by song, of whatever was playing, typically laced with heavy sarcasm. The teacher commended OneCobain’s work, which showcased outstanding originality, creativity, and sophistication. It was a pencil drawing illustrating, in 12 stages, the process of sperm transforming into a fetus. Ironically, considering his eventual destiny, Cobain appeared more fixated on birth than death. Some janitors resigned from their house cleaning jobs after encountering his collection of fetal models acquired from a medical equipment manufacturer. He used the shattered remains of some of these models to create a collage for the cover of In Utero, resulting in Walmart stores banning the record. Cobain grew disenchanted with school and dropped out, relinquishing a scholarship to an art school. He took up a janitorial role at the YMCA and resided with the family of another high school teacher, LaMont Schillinger, whose sons were his friends. Cobain came to stay for a few days after a falling out with his mother’s boyfriend. Eventually, he lived there for a year. Cobain later confided to a biographer that he began using heroin at the Schillinger family home. However, the household head believed that his former tenant was fabricating the story, mischievously attempting to craft his rock ‘n’ roll legend. The boys, remembered by LaMont Schillinger, took turns handling cooking, cleaning, and wood-cutting duties. He may also roamed the town, painting Abort Christ on the pickup trucks of born-again Christians, but at Schillinger’s dining table, he remained quiet, even during grace.
Navigating the Challenges of Success
Cobain faced a multitude of challenges on his journey to success. He grappled with the immense pressure of achieving multi-million record sales and enduring the intrusive scrutiny of the media into his private life. His life became marked by contradictions as he lived in a Seattle suburb with his daughter, a working wife, and a country home. Cobain battled with his addiction to heroin, which was siphoning $400 from him every day. He skillfully blended discordant and harmonious elements in his music within the same song, sometimes simultaneously.
Additionally, he found himself at odds with the producer of In Utero, who aimed for a rawer, less commercially oriented sound for the album. Nevertheless, Cobain emerged victorious, and his melodies often bore resemblances to the musical styles of Squeeze or The Beatles. He pledged that his future work would encompass more melodious, acoustic, and ethereal qualities.
While Generation X has faced criticism for not fully representing those in their mid-20s who were married and high-achieving, potentially outnumbering the so-called “slackers” by a factor of five to one, Cobain’s success mirrored these individuals within Generation X who may not have struggled with the system but grappled with finding their place within it.
Even stock analysts discovered solace in listening to Nirvana on their car CDs, resonating with Cobain’s disillusionment regarding success devoid of meaning. Douglas Coupland’s novel introduced the term “successophobia,” defining it as the fear that personal needs would be neglected if one succeeded. Cobain experienced a profound case of successophobia, dreading that becoming too content would render him uninteresting. To cope with this fear, he resorted to mixing his blood with the soothing elixir of heroin, although its palliative effects ultimately proved fleeting. He had contemplated naming his final album I Hate Myself and I Want to Die, but eventually decided against it, realizing it would not be perceived as a jest.
Bibliography
- Appelo, T. (2006). Desire to Burn. Poetry Foundation.
- Childers, C. (2022). 28 Years Ago: ‘Nirvana: MTV Unplugged in New York’ Released After Kurt Cobain’s Death. Loudwire.
- Fricke, D. (1994). Kurt Cobain, The Rolling Stone Interview: Success Doesn’t Suck. Rolling Stone.
- Margaritoff, M. (2023). Inside The Text Of Kurt Cobain’s Heartwrenching Suicide Note. All That’s Interesting, Something Interesting To Read Every Day.
- Mazzarella, S. R. (2008). “The voice of a generation”? Media coverage of the suicide of Kurt Cobain. Taylor & Francis Online.
- Patterson, T. (2002). The inside story of how Cobain’s journals went public. EW.com.
- Pelly, J. (2014). Watch: Aberdeen Honors “Kurt Cobain Day” With Bizarre Crying Statue. Pitchfork.
- Spiotta, D. (2022). How Kurt Cobain Dealt With Being the World’s Most Famous Outcast. Pitchfork.
- Ziek, P., & Pantic, M. (2019). From Anti-hero to Commodity: The Legacy of Kurt Cobain. The International Academic Forum.
