Controversial Reception
Since its announcement, Manhunt 2 has been surrounded by controversy, sparking discussions on the issue of video game violence. The decision to develop a sequel to one of the most gruesome, dark, and distinctive stealth action titles ever created attracted attention from watchdog groups eager to condemn the perceived increase in virtual brutality. For enthusiasts, the question was straightforward: Could the sequel match or surpass the successful mechanics of its predecessor? The anticipation heightened, fueled by the earlier ratings problem that significantly postponed the title’s release. Eventually overcoming these challenges, Rockstar London and Rockstar Games released Manhunt 2 for the PS2, PSP, and Wii. However, as players immersed themselves in the sequel, it became evident that, despite the prolonged wait, it could have captured the essence that made the original a groundbreaking experience.
The initial Manhunt transcended the realm of mere gaming; it served as a commentary on entertainment. Its premise showcased the most extreme form of personal amusement, depicting a man’s struggle for survival while a sadistic director documented every move for a series of snuff films. In contrast, the sequel diverges from this formula, choosing not to expand on the narrative of James Earl Cash, the demise of Starkweather, or establish significant connections to its forerunner. Instead, Manhunt 2 takes a daring leap into a new subject, drawing influences from works like The Manchurian Candidate and titles such as The Suffering. Without revealing plot details, the storyline explores a spectrum encompassing mind control, personality manipulation, secret medical projects, mental flashbacks, and internal struggles. This departure from the original plotline might leave some fans yearning for the thematic depth and continuity that defined the first installment.
Immersive Chaos at Dixmor
The game immerses players immediately into disorder, unveiling a rapid sequence of action within the somber confines of the Dixmor Insane Asylum. The atmosphere is unsettling, vividly portraying a location that has plunged into pure malevolence. In this distorted setting, medical professionals and attendants forsake their caregiving roles, choosing instead to subject patients to physical abuse rather than addressing their mental ailments. As anticipated, the harsh treatment administered by the staff can only persist for a limited time before the tides of karma turn into retribution. On a fateful night, a power outage shrouds the asylum in darkness, leading to the liberation of long-suppressed inmates. The situation swiftly reverses, with staff members overwhelmed as vindictive inmates seek payback. Disorder consumes every corridor and cell, reflecting the anarchy overtaking the once-controlled environment.
Amidst this turmoil, the storyline abruptly introduces the central characters, Daniel Lamb and Leo Kasper. While the initial encounter may induce disorientation, it becomes clear that this deliberate confusion aligns seamlessly with the dire circumstances faced by Danny and Leo, intensifying the atmosphere of the initial level. However, the asylum functions not as a prolonged backdrop but as a training ground where players acquaint themselves with the game’s mechanics. Here, essential elements such as navigating the radar system, assessing the alert levels of potential adversaries, and mastering the technique of stealth kills are refined. Given that the protagonists, Daniel and Leo, lack the resilience for confrontations, stealth emerges as the predominant aspect of the game. Survival requires adept maneuvering in the shadows, strategically timing attacks on unsuspecting targets, and tactically separating groups of enemies.
The emphasis on stealth is further underscored through the strategic use of sound. Players can manipulate their surroundings by tossing objects to divert attention or utilizing a USB headset to generate distracting noises, drawing enemies away from their companions. This intricate integration of gameplay mechanics elevates the level of challenge. It immerses players in a tense and strategic experience, where each move becomes crucial for survival in this distressing and unpredictable realm.
Heightened Complexity with Quick Time Events
In contrast to the initial installment, where players had the convenience of diverting enemies and rapidly seeking refuge in the shadows, Manhunt 2 introduces an added layer of complexity by integrating quick-time events triggered when hunters in your proximity initiate a search. The ease of avoiding detection is no longer assured, and depending on the hunters’ search intensity, a combination of buttons will appear on the screen, demanding swift and precise inputs to elude detection. Failing this challenge results in an immediate extraction from the shadows and a merciless throttling from the adversary. Conversely, success in these quick-time events renders the hunters entirely oblivious to your presence, enabling players to proceed with the elimination in diverse ways. Similar to the first game, players can choose from three distinct levels of dispatching enemies based on the timing of their strikes. Opting for a Hasty kill allows for the swift elimination of a nearby hunter while delaying the attack opens the door to Violent or even Gruesome kills. The higher the attack level, the longer the triggered animation lasts, with certain Gruesome kills extending for over five seconds, while Hasty kills can conclude in just one or two.
Significantly, Manhunt 2 broadens the array of lethal options beyond conventional weapons. Players can now dispose of enemies through environmental kills, such as setting them ablaze, smashing them with manhole covers, or ensnaring them in iron maidens. The gameplay introduces the opportunity for leaping kills from elevated positions, enabling players to deliver devastating blows to unsuspecting hunters below, often resulting in brutal skull-crushing animations. As the game advances and players acquire firearms, a new facet is incorporated into the arsenal. Gun executions become a practical choice, providing players with the ability to eliminate enemies from a distance efficiently. This versatile approach to combat in Manhunt 2 offers players various strategies, ensuring that the gameplay remains dynamic and captivating as they navigate the ominous and challenging world of relentless pursuit and strategic survival.
Expectations of Unsettling Targets
Certainly, in a game that strongly emphasizes eliminating opponents, one might expect the targets of your aggressive pursuits to possess a certain unsettling quality, providing a rationale for the displayed extreme aggression. However, this installment sees none of the gangs from the previous title returning, forcing players to acquaint themselves with an entirely new set of adversaries. Each gang introduces its own distinctive visual identity and hunting strategy, adding complexity to the player’s experience. For example, the Pervs, a group of bikers frequenting areas near a sex club, rely on sheer strength and territorial roaming. At the same time, the Bloodhounds, Southern mercenaries with hoods and masks reminiscent of the War Dogs from the original game, prefer moving in pairs to track your every move.
These gangs go beyond being formidable opponents; they employ diverse tactics to challenge players, including sudden turns or doubling back, necessitating adjustments in timing for attacks or distraction noises to avoid detection. Some gangs even integrate flashlights into their arsenal, sweeping them across shadowy areas to pinpoint your location. Despite these innovative tactics, the enemy AI occasionally exposes flaws, exhibiting behaviors that border the absurd. For instance, certain enemies may run in place or repeatedly turn back and forth without paying attention to the player’s actions, resulting in a noticeable breakdown in their hunting behavior.
This flaw becomes particularly evident with enemies equipped with flashlights, who occasionally abandon using these items during their alert and suspicion states. In a specific scenario, after being spotted by an officer who called for reinforcements armed with flashlights, we led them across the level for a considerable duration. Upon escaping into an open shed and pressing against a wall, most pursuers expressed confusion about my whereabouts. They neglected to check the shed with their flashlights, which would have been the most obvious place for me to hide. The breakdown of the hunting aspect of the game becomes apparent in such instances, and it is disheartening to observe a seemingly straightforward tactic undermining the immersive experience intended by the game.
Absence of Intense Danger in Manhunt 2
It highlights a notable issue—the absence of the intense sense of danger and malevolence that characterized the original title. In the initial Manhunt, players were compelled to proceed cautiously, acutely aware of the pervasive peril lurking around every corner. However, in Manhunt 2, the dynamics have shifted. Players can actively manipulate shadows by breaking lights and evade detection and potential threats by exploiting ambient noise from machinery or loud music. Consequently, the constant looming danger of being ambushed by multiple deranged or perverted thugs fueled by adrenaline and drugs feels less immediate. The sense of being on the verge of a violent encounter has waned, allowing for more uninhibited movement through environments, with the luxury of choosing when to eliminate each enemy at one’s discretion.
Moreover, the diminished fear that gangs will relentlessly pursue the player is evident, as the AI lacks the same relentless and menacing quality. This alteration in the game’s atmosphere may also be attributed to the story is somewhat disjointed and scattered nature. While the intention may have been to capitalize on the theme of sanity, it comes across as clichéd and superficial, especially when compared to more nuanced executions in other games or movies. The reduced sense of imminent danger, as experienced in the original title, makes it easy to disconnect from each character. Eliminating enemies becomes a means to advance to the next area, with the repetition lacking a heightened sense of urgency.
Furthermore, the predictability of narrative events detracts from the immersive experience; despite the ease with which enemies can be dispatched, lingering questions emerge, such as the ongoing threat posed by The Project that imprisoned Danny and Leo, irrespective of the chosen ending. The relatively straightforward nature of enemy encounters raises doubts about the protagonists facing significant danger in the future. This departure from the original title’s intense atmosphere and the storyline’s predictability contributes to a less captivating and immersive experience in Manhunt 2.
Firearm Potency and Aggressive Playstyle
It becomes notably apparent when obtaining firearms in the game. Similar to the original, there is a waiting period before acquiring weapons like pistols, machine guns, and sniper rifles. However, once armed with these potent tools, the temptation to adopt a more aggressive playstyle arises, allowing for the effortless dispatch of opponents—particularly those who remain stationary while under fire. Despite the game’s efforts to vary enemy placements and introduce challenges like spawning thugs behind players in specific stages, the overwhelming firepower of these weapons often eclipses any potential difficulty. It is noteworthy that many enemies wielding these firearms display poor marksmanship. While confronting someone with a shotgun may result in a hit, handling crossbows, pistols, and other firearms becomes a relatively straightforward task with basic tactics and quick trigger reflexes.
Two additional minor issues emerge in the title, although they carry some impact. The first pertains to the somewhat rigid movement of Danny and Leo through their environments, particularly noticeable when executing a kill and attempting to reposition in the shadows to attract another enemy. Their turning feels akin to maneuvering a tank, lacking the fluidity that could enhance the overall experience. Consequently, players might find themselves readjusting to the shadows during stealth kill animations to gain a head start as soon as the animation concludes. While these nuances are relatively small, they contribute to the overall gameplay experience and deserve consideration in evaluating the title.
Animation Disappointment: Censorship and Lack of Brutality
Discussing the animations, it is somewhat disheartening to observe the kills being as heavily censored in this game as they are. The initial installment stood out due to its intense brutality and exaggerated nature. The inclusion of a character donning a pig’s head and exposed genitals amid violent kills was truly groundbreaking. Unfortunately, Manhunt 2 falls short of achieving the same level of excess. No character is comparable to Piggsy, and every kill, whether a swift strike or a brutal environmental takedown, lacks the vividness seen in the first game, resembling the desaturation seen in the “The Punisher” game released a few years prior. To compound matters, the frequent shifts of the camera on and off the action detract from the feeling of harshly dispatching enemies. Consequently, the distinguishing element that made the original title stand out feels diluted in its presentation. The emotional impact of the kills is diminished, depriving players of the same impactful and memorable experiences that characterized the predecessor.
However, the visual presentation of the title remains unscathed, retaining the same striking quality as the original. Whether navigating the chaotic walls of an insane asylum or the sordid levels of a sex club, the environments maintain a commendable level of realism. The meticulous attention to detail in depicting these gritty settings enhances the overall immersive experience of the game. This commitment to visual excellence is a testament to the developers’ dedication to crafting an aesthetically captivating journey that aligns with the dark themes of the narrative. A noteworthy feature is the game’s visual representation linked to the sanity premise, where weapons and healing items vibrate and shake, instilling doubt about their existence or whether they are figments of Danny and Leo’s minds. This subtle yet impactful detail introduces a layer of psychological tension to the gameplay, keeping players on edge and reinforcing the blurred boundary between reality and the distorted perceptions of the characters.
This contrast is particularly evident in the visual styles of the various hunter “gangs.” While there may not be anything as visually striking as a character sporting a smiley face while wielding a bloody baseball bat, the game presents a diverse array of characters donning leather masks, clad in leather or suits, or outfitted in military fatigues. Each gang’s distinct visual identity contributes to the overall diversity of the game world, creating a visually engaging experience that complements the gritty narrative.
Captivating Allure Comparison: Manhunt 2 vs. Original Title
The gaming experience boasts consistently impressive audio, whether engaging in noise tactics to divert enemies or immersing oneself in the environmental soundscape. The voice acting stands out for its commendable quality, with nearly every line delivered with skill and authenticity. Despite the censorship applied to the kills, the unfiltered language introduces a layer of raw realism to the dialogue, featuring a profusion of cursing and coarse language intertwined with witty remarks. It contributes to a compelling and dynamic conversation track. The meticulous attention to detail extends to the sound effects, encompassing everything from the shattering of glass to the visceral sounds of beheading foes with axes. These elements collectively contribute to an outstanding ambient environment, enhancing the gaming experience. Having successfully navigated both the original and Manhunt 2 at various difficulty levels, it is satisfying to witness Rockstar’s attempt to evolve this into a franchise. However, the sequel has relinquished some of the essence present in the original.
In contrast to its predecessor, Manhunt 2 falls short in several aspects. Artificial intelligence (AI) lacks the same level of sophistication seen in the first game, the settings lack a menacing atmosphere, and the overall narrative seems weaker. While Manhunt 2 still qualifies as a good game, providing an enjoyable experience in Danny and Leo’s adventure, especially for those familiar with the first title and eager to dispatch enemies with unconventional items like plastic bags and crowbars, it does not quite attain the same level of excellence as its predecessor. It is crucial to acknowledge that Manhunt 2 is not without merit; it effectively captures the essence of the original game. However, as a comprehensive experience, it possesses a different captivating allure than enthralled players in the first installment. Despite this, for franchise fans and those seeking a thrilling adventure, Manhunt 2 still delivers a satisfying gaming experience, even if it does not quite reach the pinnacle established by its predecessor.
Bibliography
- Fahey, R. (2004). New twist to Manhunt murder allegations. GamesIndustry.biz.
- Haynes, J. (2012). Manhunt 2 Review. IGN.
- Ingram, T. (2007). Murder victim’s parents condemn Manhunt sequel. MCV.
- Tolito, S. (2007). Manhunt 2 Developer Finally Talks About Game, Ratings Controversy – Much As It Pains Him. MTV.